Vendor Evaluation and Selection Matrix

Jawad Ahmad


Jawad Ahmad

Vendor Evaluation and Selection Matrix

Table of Contents

When onboarding new vendors, it takes the new company an average of 90 days to fulfill due diligence.

So, in a competitive business environment where speed determines the success or failures, a lengthy onboarding process weakens your organization’s energies at digital transformation and growth acceleration.

While in today’s globally linked world, international vendors provide products to clients thousands of miles away; finding operational efficiencies in your onboarding process is more important than ever.

So organizations need to do business with suppliers that provide the best and speedy value. Hence we need to know the performance of these vendors. To achieve this objective, we use a vendor selection matrix. So let’s have a look at what is a vendor.

Related Article: Purchase Requisition Format Excel 

vendor evaluation and selection matrix

What Is Vendor Assessment?

Vendor assessment describes an organization’s evaluation and approval process of assessing its vendors’ management of that organization’s information and whether these vendors and suppliers can meet their organizational obligations and standards once under contract. Also, vendor assessment’s end goal is to establish guidelines to establish a secure, best-in class, low-risk vendor, and supplier portfolio.

A vendor assessment program is a part of an organization’s extensive program of maintaining its customer and internal data. Also, organizations will pursue a security review of active and potential vendors, and vendors and suppliers must show that they have practices to secure the data.

Further, through vendor assessment programs, organizations ensure that their vendors and reliably compliant with required policies and procedures.

Project Management 150 Templates Bundle Ad

Vendor Evaluation And Selection Matrix

Selecting a vendor is one of the most important activities a business must undertake. Because when you are selecting a vendor, you are choosing a partner in your industry.

Also, it is vital to select a vendor or supplier that can fulfill your requirements quickly. So, to select this, the Vendor Evaluation and selection matrix tool helps you a lot.

Moreover, this tool establishes a side-by-side comparison of your potential vendor offerings. Further, with this vendor selection matrix, you can ensure the best possible vendor selection decision.

It is easy to use and flexible. Just click and get a fantastic vendor comparison matrix. Also, this vendor selection template is tailored for information and Communication Technology project.

Thus, for such projects, you typically have some features that a vendor’s product must provide you. However, to ensure the best vendor choice, this vendor selection scorecard also enables an evaluation of the vendor/s support, service, implementation process, and costs aspects.

Using this vendor evaluation matrix, you can list each risk, its likelihood, and severity, all in one single chart.

Related Article: Supply Chain Management (SCM)

Supplier and Vendor Assessment Framework

A supplier and Vendor selection criteria framework helps an organized approach to select potential vendors. Also, this framework works on a standard criterion determining potential vendors’ suitability and any risks that they can cause to your company.

The assessment framework helps you determine the best suppliers and vendors based on price and a full spectrum of concerns.

Dr. Carter made a Vendor and supplier assessment framework when he saw that wrong supplier selection causes business breakdowns. Carter,s 10 C Supplier, and Vendor assessment Evaluation Model assess a potential supplier’s suitability.

You can use them as a checklist when deciding who to avoid and who to approach.

The 10 C’s are:

  1. Competency
  2. Capacity
  3. Commitment
  4. Control
  5. Cash
  6. Cost
  7. Consistency
  8. Culture
  9. Clean
  10. Communication

Competency: Request that suppliers produce evidence that their products have been demonstrated to be high quality with other clients and investigate their training and development procedures, qualification records, essential staff background and talents, and recruitment practices.


  • Investigate prospective partners’ current and projected orders and customers and how this affects their capability to satisfy your current and expected requirements.
  • Consider how this influences the ability of prospective partners to attract new clients.
  • Inquire about operational statistics concerning problems with quality or service levels; they should be readily available if the provider is ISO 9000 accredited.
  • Read “The Ultimate Guide to ISO 9000” to get more information about this accreditation.

Commitment to Quality: Regularly audits the organization’s policies and processes to supervise and control quality and ensure conformity to relevant industry standards, such as ISO 9000 and HIPAA.

Control of Internal Processes: Inquire about the company’s procedures for controlling inventories, quality control activities, procurement, marketing, distribution, and health and safety.

Cash and Finance: You should collaborate with an organization in a sound financial position. Ensure you get up-to-date lists of fixed and current assets, profit and loss (P&L) statements, and credit rating paperwork.

Cost: Determine if the product or service can be delivered at an affordable price to maintain a healthy relationship with your Vendor or supplier.

Consistency of Performance: Ensure that your potential future partner will be capable of delivering consistently high levels of quality and service over the entire contract by ensuring they can maintain a constant level of performance. For instance, you should search for a provider that provides a single point of contact in the form of an account manager who is committed to quality control and oversight; this demonstrates the provider’s dedication to high performance.

Culture: Before you get into a contract with a possible partner, you should first determine whether or not the two of you have compatible values and approaches to the workplace. People with the same worldview make working interactions easier to navigate and facilitate the formation of lasting partnerships.

Clean (Corporate Social Responsibility): Conformity to legal and environmental norms and criteria is required of all products and services provided by vendors and suppliers as part of the company’s commitment to its corporate social responsibility.

Communication: Make sure that your Vendor or supplier will set up and manage (or conform to your current) communications channels in person with your account manager and other key staff, virtually with meetings, or digitally with collaborative tools.

The 7Cs

Risk Assessment Matrix Template

You can save time and money and support the trust and your organization’s reputation by completing rigorous due diligence before engaging a vendor or supplier. In conducting your due diligence, you should base your decisions on criteria relevant to you and your organization. This criterion may take precedence over concerns regarding cost or efficiency.

Identify Top Vendors: You’ll be able to locate vendors who have the reputation, abilities, and understanding to solve your company’s problems by using a mix of your important vendor selection criteria and a risk assessment.

Cut Down on Costs: Although cost shouldn’t be the deciding factor in any situation, researching the best available vendors and the competitive landscape can help you save money in the long run by avoiding the costs associated with bad service and delivery. Additionally, once you have established your relationship with the vendors, they may provide future chances to lower expenses further through volume discounts or continuity savings.

Boost Your Efficiency: The capacity of a company to respond swiftly and move quickly is directly proportional to the fluidity of the flow of your supply chain. If you have ongoing monitoring, you will be able to identify inefficiencies as soon as they appear and, in collaboration with your Vendor or supplier, find a solution to fix them before it is too late.

Strengthen Relationships: Effective vendor management helps strengthen your brand and supports mutually productive working relationships that serve everyone in the long run and boost your reputation. This type of management also encourages communication, collaboration, and loyalty.

Improve Your Business: Proper vetting will assist you in engaging notable vendors and will make it possible for you to deliver items or services that are of higher quality and at prices that are more competitive.

Your consumers will appreciate the improved level of service they receive as a direct result of this. In addition, as your ability to make effective decisions improves, you can anticipate increased customer loyalty and sales.

Vendor Assessment Criteria

Vendor Assessment Criteria helps you support your company’s goals, mission, ethics in the area of cost and financial integrity, technical competence, and quality, ability to communicate, cultural commitments, and social responsibility.

Moreover, when selecting vendors and suppliers, you should review the criteria that matter to your organization’s goals. For example, suppose your business looks for a Pizza Box company.

In that case, essential concerns might be designs and dimensions and a reply to a custom review against standard portions and shipping stability.

Further, to gather a criterion on vendors and suppliers, use this Vendor and Supplier Assessment Criteria Checklist and access your potential business partners.

Also, you can apply these criteria to your potential Vendor and use them to evaluate and rate current partners. Also, the vendor selection matrix template includes areas to document corrective actions and observations.

But to reflect your company’s criteria, you must adjust it accordingly. Additionally, vendor selection matrix excel contains an RFP scoring matrix system that makes it easy to rank vendors and suppliers individually.

You can use this template to aggregate scores to make comparisons.

Different Methods of Vendor Evaluation

Not a single vendor evaluation method, except the evaluation scoring matrix, covers every situation. It will help if you consider your business and the vendor classification while evaluating vendors. Below is a list of ways that you can use to conduct your vendor evaluation:

Commercial: If you evaluate a vendor from a commercial perspective, keep in mind their market dominance, reputation, market presence, existing clients, and ability to deliver promptly.

Records: In this type of evaluation, you collect vendors’ data from public sources, such as industry news items, financial records, and award notices.

Technical: A technical vendor evaluation focuses on innovation, compliance, scientific capabilities, and specialized equipment.

Before-the-Fact: In this vendor evaluation type, you plan and gather data from public data resources and supplier or vendor reviews early in the project’s history.

In this type of vendor evaluation, the evaluator reviews the first engagement and assess performance. Then he asks stakeholders about failures, success, and operations. Collected responses help the evaluator in decision-making.

The best way is to use a vendor evaluation template Excel. Which is made for your ease.

Related Article: Construction Lump Sum Contracts


Here is a Six-Step process that you must adopt for a successful vendor selection:

Kick-Off and Requirements definition

First, make a project team that has common interests in the vendor evaluation process. Then, together with the team, define the requirements of services or products. Also, define specifications of service, including service levels. Further, the vendor selection flowchart is ready to use a template that makes your selection process easy.

Market research

This step aims to get the first list of vendors and suppliers for which you want to start an RFP. Then do market research for vendors who could meet your requirements. Further, RFP evaluation template is the best tool that helps you find a suitable vendor for your business.

Request for proposal

Based on your requirements, request selected suppliers or vendors to respond to your needs. Construct your RFP clear, and don’t overcommunicate vendors when they contact you to take information about other vendor offerings.

Evaluate responses.

Before evaluating the Vendor’s responses, build an evaluation sheet based on the request for a response. Also, by assessing each Vendor’s criteria and evaluating each supplier or vendor response against these criteria, you can get a total score per supplier. So, to define and structure this criterion efficiently, download our supplier selection matrix excel template to minimize your efforts.

Proof of concept

PoC helps you checking the Vendor’s actual capability. Additionally, PoC is an excellent instrument to get general impressions of the Vendor.

Select Vendor

Finally, it is time to make the final choice. Based on the results from the Proof of Concept, you can revise some scores. To make the decision, look at the total scores and killer criteria and rank vendors accordingly. Consider using supplier evaluation criteria checklist excel to make your task easier.

Six steps for a successful vendor

Benefits of Vendor Assessment

Although the vendor assessment process is challenging, its benefits are enormous. Let’s have a look at these benefits:

Lower Regulatory Compliance Risk

Vendor assessments confirm compliance with the laws, regulations, and standards that affect your business.

Risk Mitigation

By carefully evaluating vendors, you can lower the contract, regulatory, and security risks of working with vendors outside your company.

Decrease Security and Cyber Risks

As we grow our business, the cyber risk grows. Therefore, it is essential to protect your customer and company data as well. So, your vendor comparison matrix should focus on reviewing a third-party vendor to your store data. Also, make sure that the Vendor or supplier takes the proper security measures to protect and encrypt your data. Once you have identified your potential vendors, have them answer some questions that thoroughly cover security management system details.

Scope of Contract Compliance

Conduct a legal review of nondisclosure agreements or partnership agreements to ensure you have set a satisfactory condition and alleviate any risks.

Risk Mitigation

You can reduce the regulatory, contractual, and security risks associated with interacting with entities outside of your firm if you properly evaluate the vendors and suppliers with whom you do business.

Lower Regulatory Compliance Risk

Confirming compliance with the laws, rules, and standards that apply to your company can help reduce the risk of non-compliance with regulatory compliance requirements. If your supplier is located in another nation or if you sell to customers in another country, you should research both countries’ legal requirements. For instance, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) applies to your operations if they occur within the European Union (EU).

Scope of Service and Compliance with Contracts

Carry out a legal examination of the terms of any contracts, nondisclosure agreements (NDAs), or partnership agreements in place to ensure that you have created favorable conditions and reduced any risks.

Lessen the Dangers of Cybercrime and Increased Security

The threat of cybercrime is growing as more and more of our work is moved to the cloud. As a result, it is necessary to safeguard the information about both your business and your customers. The evaluation of a third-party vendor or supplier to keep your data must take up most of your time during the choosing process.

First, it is necessary to recognize and assess the kinds of data vendors and suppliers would require access to. Then it is necessary to determine if it is necessary for them to access all of it, some of it, or none, to carry out their duties.

It is important to check that the provider encrypts and protects your data using the appropriate protocols. Once you have identified possible partners, you should have them fill out a questionnaire that comprehensively covers the features of your security management system.

Top 3 Mistakes

Evaluate Vendor On their Capabilities

One of the common mistakes is to select a vendor only ‍on the proposal. Despite this, you should consider some points while evaluating a vendor. Firstly, consider the Vendor’s capability to deliver and what it will be like working with him. Are there signs that the Vendor wants to win the bid? Proof of Concept (5) can be beneficial to judge this. Finally, include this point as a killer Criteria in your vendor evaluation process.

Avoid Communication Blunders

The second mistake you should avoid while vendor selection is giving the Vendor any information about competitors’ offerings. This mistake can jeopardize the whole selection process and effects your credibility. So always guard your tongue whenever a vendor contacts you during the selection process. It is good to use a vendor selection criteria template.

Formulate RFP Well

This 3rd mistake that you should avoid while the selection process is not to formulate your RFP well. You should give clear instructions to the Vendor if you want to get the exact proposal structure. If your RFP is not clear, every proposal will come in a different form. Moreover, if you don’t formulate your RFP well, then the vendors’ responses will be based on assumptions and you will start the whole process again from scratch.

Construction Project 50 Templates Bundle

Top 10 Frequently Asked Questions about Vendor Evaluation and Selection Matrix

There are many questions in the FAQ list of Vendor Evaluation and Selection Matrix. However, the top 10 and the basic ones are:

What are the 4 stages of supplier selection?

The 4 stages of vendor selection are:
Evaluating Offers.
Operational Capacity Analysis.
Technical Capability Determination.
Financial Analysis.

What is supplier selection?

Supplier selection is the process by which a company identifies, evaluate, and deal with suppliers. So, the supplier selection Matrix’s principal objective is to lessen purchase risk, boost overall value to the purchaser, and create long-term connections between buyers and suppliers.

Why is vendor selection important?

Vendor evaluation is crucial as it reduces supply chain costs and improves the quality and timeliness of delivering items to your organization.

What are the three main components of choosing a supplier?

Three main components you should consider while selecting a supplier are:
1. Negotiating prices.
2. Import from domestic suppliers.
3. Reliability.

What are the five steps involved in the vendor selection framework?

Steps to a Successful Vendor Selection Framework are:
1. Evaluate your business requirements.
2. Search for a vendor.
3. Write an RFP & RFQ.
4. Evaluate the proposal and select the Vendor.
5. Create a contract negotiation strategy.

Why do we evaluate suppliers?

Because the purpose of evaluating suppliers is to ensure a range of best-in-class suppliers available for use.

What is vendor performance evaluation?

Vendor performance management shows the purpose of internal performance reviews. It is a vital part of smart financial management.

What is supplier evaluation and selection?

The supplier evaluation process is the base of strategic sourcing and the foundation of supply advantage. So, the evaluation process’s overall objective is to lessen the purchasing risk and expand the fundamental value to the customer.

How do you choose the vendor criteria?

We will count His:
1. Years in business
2. Ability to continuously supply products or services.
3. Capacity to supply all the products required.
4. Flexibility to accept changes in product lines.
5. Extensive catalog of products.

What are the three most important criteria for selecting suppliers?

The following criteria are required:
1. Price
2. Quality
3. Value for money
4. Reliability
5. Flexibility
6. Responsiveness

Finally, it was all about the “Vendor Evaluation and Selection Matrix”. Please do share your feedback in the comments section and keep visiting us to learn more about Project Management.

Graphic Resources Credit: Designed by Freepik

Subscribe to get the Pack of 50 Templates for FREE